The Hawes Inn by Innkeeper's Collection

Pros: Das Zimmer 10 und 5 waren hervorragend. Super gross und sehr hübsch eingerichtet. Das Essen im Restaurant war sehr fein. Cons: Das Frühstück sollte bereits ab 7.30 möglich sein, wegen den Flügen am Flughafen.

Great location, room (especially bathroom) needs serious maintenance which I believe the hotel doesn’t want to carry out

Pros: The location is amazing, and the pub is really nice. Cons: Tons of mold in the bathroom (pictures below),which stinks up the whole room. Extractor fan barely functions so it doesn’t alleviate the smell. Sink plugged. The staff told us they were too busy to do anything about either issue.

Pros: The meals were excellent and lots of choices. Its setting on the Marina is lovely and the Inn has an "Old World Charm" about it. At night it did get noisy outside with cars/motorbike traffic being right on the roadway! Cons: The Staff were pleasant but when requested there was no Tourist Information Brochures available or offered by Staff or in the Room. We would have expected a range of info ready to provide to Visitors noting places to look out for, best modes of transport and parking into Edinburgh. The room was warm when the heating kicked in at night and the bed was comfortable but

Great location but a boy racer magnet.

Pros: Location and access to local train travel into Edinburgh Waverley. Great food. Comfortable rooms. Welcoming and helpful staff. Cons: The noise late on a night from local 'boy racers' in their cars travelling up and down the road in the village. Both nights still revving engines and loud exhausts till approximately 1am. It's a magnet for motorbike and car meets. The pub was also closed early on the Saturday night when we got back from the city around 10pm with no prior notice. Would have been nice to have a nightcap in the pub after a long day.

Great location and rooms but the service and food do not live up to the location and room.

Pros: The welcome upon arrival was cold and unhelpful. The location and room were both great. Cons: The food and service were very poor. I had a steak for dinner and it was inedible. I sent it back and was offered another meal, which was a Cesar salad and that was also not very good. Breakfast was also of poor standard.